Three guests check into a hotel. The Cashier says the bill is $30 so each pays $10. Later the cashier realizes the bill should only be $25. To rectify he gives the bellhop five singles to return to the guests. On the way back to the room the bellhop realizes that he cannot divide the money evenly. As they didnâ€™t know the total of the revised bill, he decides to give each guest a dollar and keep two for himself.

Now that the guests have been given a dollar back, each has paid $9. Three times nine is 27 and the bellhop has $2. Two plus 27 is 29. If the guests originally handed over $30, what happened to the remaining dollar?

Solution

We unravel this confusion by recognizing that there is no reason to add $2 to $27. It should be subtracted.

The $3 amount that has been returned to the guests is a reduction in the amount that the guests paid, so it should be subtracted from the total. The bellhop returned $3 ($1 each), making their total payment $27 (mathematically, $30 - $3). Note that the $3 is subtracted from the total. If the bellhop then changed his mind and returned the additional $2 to the guests, it would also be subtracted from the total. The mistake is made in trying to add this $2 instead of subtracting it. Simple math demonstrates what readers intuitively sense, that there is no missing money. The sum of their payments is $25 in the till, $2 in the bellhop's pocket (totaling $27), plus the $3 in change that the guests now have, which brings the total up to $30.

The incorrect solution is: ($10 - $1) x 3 + $2 = $29. This equation is not meaningful: the number 29 is not significant to the problem, i.e. there is no "missing $1".

The correct solution is: ($10 - $1) x 3 - $2 = $25. In this case the solution is the bill amount, which is also the amount of money left in the till.

In other words, $27 is the amount that the guests have paid. Of that $27, $25 went into the till and $2 went to the bellhop. The other $3 is returned to the guests.

This problem provides a means to understand how misdirection, and irrelevant facts and questions, can foil clear analysis. Additionally, the tools used to resolve this paradox are used in the analysis of a wide range of financial and scientific areas.

Misdirection

The problem's second paragraph states five truths:

Each of the guests paid $9; Three times 9 is 27.; The bellhop has $2 in his pocket.; Two plus 27 is $29.; The guests originally handed over $30.;

Unfortunately, No. 4 is a misdirection. In this problem, we wonder about what is going in and out of folks' pockets, and how much is staying there. However, to think about pockets correctly (and to write sensible math), you must mentally draw a circle around each pocket, and count everything that goes in and out of that single pocket. Thus, the equation for one pocket must be derived from what goes in and out of that (same) one pocket. No. 4 confuses what the bellhop kept ($2), and what the guests think they spent ($27), thus mixing up pockets.

Read more at Wikipedia.org





		Aspects Hummzinger Hummingbird Feeder 8 oz capacity $14.79			Aspects 12oz Hummzinger Ultra With Nectar Guard $16.00

		Stokes Select STK5137-14 Cardinal Songbird Select			Opus 443 Garden Song 8-Ounce Instant Hummingbird Nectar $2.39

		Droll Yankee Window Mount Hummer Feeder W/ Nectar Guard $17.99			Fluker's 1.9 oz Freeze Dried Mealworms $6.37

		SUMMIT CHEMICAL 11591 "SQUIRREL AWAY" REPELLENT 1.5 OZ $2.19			Aspects Hummzinger Hummingbird Feeder 16 Ounce $17.69

		Oriole Food, 8oz $1.59			Opus 4443-4 Ready-To-Use Hummingbird Nectar $5.99

		Oriole Nectar, 33.8 Oz $3.29			Droll Yankee Hummingbird Feeder With Nectar Guard $15.99

		National Audubon Society Cherry Cobbler			C. & S. Prod. 526 Bluebird Treat $3.19

		Timbuktu Outdoors Birdwatcher's Choice Mealworms $16.99			CAREFREE ENZYMES 94721 3B PROTECTOR CLEANER $10.99

		KAYTEE WILD BIRD FOOD 20 LB $8.50			Red River Commodities 678 Finch Sock $4.62

		Stokes Select STK5083-07 Critter Snack Select			National Audubon Society Sunflower Hearts

		Valley Splendor Cracked Corn			National Audubon Society Finch Festival

		Outdoor Seasons 233 Clear Hummingbird Nectar $1.99			Wild Bird Feast #128 $5.95

		NYJER BIRD SEED 4.9# $13.75			Opus 446-24 Instant Hummingbird Food $1.47

		Stokes Select STK5571-07 Finch Select			PERKY PET 32oz Dew Drop Hummingbird Feeder $3.13

		Opus 481-12 Classic Nyjer Seed Finch Feeder $4.99			Red River Commodities 297 Valley Splendor Sunrise Blend $4.79

		Red River Commodities 368 Valley Splendor Fruit And Nut Seed Blend $4.79			Valley Splendor Large Striped Sunflower Seeds

		Red River Commodities 557 Stokes Certified Finch Select Seed $9.99			Red River Commodities 592 Stokes Select Wild Bird Food $3.27

		C. & S. Prod. 502 High-Energy Suet Brick $3.53			ARTLINE Red Hummingbird Nectar Mix $8.05

		Peanut Butter Suet-Sandwich $4.99			Red River Commodities 676 Wild Bird Bell - 8 Per Box $19.99

		Red River Commodities 583 Stokes Premium Safflower $9.99			Choice Insect Suet Cakes (Case of 12) $24.99

		KAYTEE PRODUCTS INC. 100033780 5LB Nut/Berry Bird Food (6 pack) $8.59			Stokes Select STK5434-10 Premium Black Oil Sunflower

		Opus 101-4 Dine Around Window Bird Feeder $6.37			Zoo Med Can O Worms $3.60

		Choice Peanut Suet Cakes (Case of 12) $22.99			Perky Pet Products 230 8-Ounce Instant Nectar $1.31

		Red River Commodities 524 Stokes Select Nyjer Seed $19.99			Stokes Select STK5908-10 Thistle

		WOODLINK Daiquiri Hummingbird Feeder $12.89			C. & S. Prod. 12680 Peanut Delight Suet Plug $2.45

		Outdoor Seasons 283 Oriole Food $1.50			Nyjer and Thistle Seed - 5 lb. $10.99

		National Audubon Society Sunflower Melody			Red River Commodities 387 Striped Sunflower Seed $6.47

		38-oz. Aluminum Scoop $15.95			58-oz. Aluminum Scoop $18.55

		85 oz. Aluminum Scoop $21.68			ART LINE INC #5585 8OZ RED Nectar Powder $1.55

		Artline 5.3 Ounce Clear Instant Nectar $6.99			Artline 5.3 Ounce Red Instant Nectar $6.99

		Artline 8 Ounce Clear Instant Nectar $7.49			Artline 8 Ounce Instant Oriole Nectar $7.49

		ARTLINE Hummingbird Book $3.81			Best-1 8 Ounce Hummingbird Instant Nectar $8.49

		Best-1 Instant Nectar Jumbo Jar $8.78			C & S Products Almond Treat Suet $7.78

		C & S Products Apple Delight Suet $1.87			C & S PRODUCTS CO INC 105 27OZ Peanut Flav Nugget (12 pack) $3.18

		C & S Products Insect Suet Delight $3.99			C & S Products Orange Dough $7.49

		C & S Products Peanut Boost Ball Plugs $10.78			C & S Products Peanut Treat $7.49

		C & S Products Raisin Dough $7.49			C & S Products Raisin Treat Suet - 11.75 Ounce $5.95

		C & S Products Woodpecker Mini Snak $1.80			C & S Products Woodpecker Treat Suet $2.59

		C&S PRODUCTS 12507 HIGH ENERGY SUET DOUGH & PEANUTS 11-3/4 OZ $1.49			C&S PRODUCTS 12515 RAISIN DELIGHT SUET 11.75 oz. $1.99

		C&S PRODUCTS 12517 CALCIUM SUET DOUGH 13.25 OZ $1.99			C&S PRODUCTS 12555 PECAN DELIGHT SUET 11-3/4 OZ $2.59

		C. & S. Prod. 06209 Fruit And Nut Seed Snak Cake $6.69			C. & S. Prod. 101 Suet Nuggets $2.96

		C. & S. Prod. 103 Suet Nuggets $2.86			C. & S. Prod. 105 Suet Nuggets $2.96

		C. & S. Prod. 12501 High-Energy Suet Cake $1.22			C. & S. Prod. 12509 Peanut Treat Suet Cake $2.07

		C. & S. Prod. 12513 Party Mix Suet Cake $2.23			C. & S. Prod. 12517 Calcium Suet Cake $2.07

		C. & S. Prod. 12529 Orange Suet Cake $2.07			C. & S. Prod. 12531 Insect Treat Suet Cake $2.55

		C. & S. Prod. 12535 Cherry Treat Suet Cake $1.75			C. & S. Prod. 12543 Berry Delight Suet Dough $1.92

		C. & S. Prod. 12545 Apple Suet Cake $2.07			C. & S. Prod. 12549 Fruitn'Nut Treat Suet Cake $2.29

		C. & S. Prod. 12553 Hot Pepper Suet Cake $2.23			C. & S. Prod. 12681 Orange Delight Suet Plug $2.45

		C. & S. Prod. 12687 Insect Treat Suet Plug $2.45			C. & S. Prod. 12689 Woodpecker Treat Suet Plug $2.38

		C. & S. Prod. 155 Ultra Blend Nuggets $6.50			C. & S. Prod. 24251 Finch Snak Cake $2.29

Home

Contact

Resources

Exchange Links

eBay