Three guests check into a hotel. The Cashier says the bill is $30 so each pays $10. Later the cashier realizes the bill should only be $25. To rectify he gives the bellhop five singles to return to the guests. On the way back to the room the bellhop realizes that he cannot divide the money evenly. As they didnâ€™t know the total of the revised bill, he decides to give each guest a dollar and keep two for himself.

Now that the guests have been given a dollar back, each has paid $9. Three times nine is 27 and the bellhop has $2. Two plus 27 is 29. If the guests originally handed over $30, what happened to the remaining dollar?

Solution

We unravel this confusion by recognizing that there is no reason to add $2 to $27. It should be subtracted.

The $3 amount that has been returned to the guests is a reduction in the amount that the guests paid, so it should be subtracted from the total. The bellhop returned $3 ($1 each), making their total payment $27 (mathematically, $30 - $3). Note that the $3 is subtracted from the total. If the bellhop then changed his mind and returned the additional $2 to the guests, it would also be subtracted from the total. The mistake is made in trying to add this $2 instead of subtracting it. Simple math demonstrates what readers intuitively sense, that there is no missing money. The sum of their payments is $25 in the till, $2 in the bellhop's pocket (totaling $27), plus the $3 in change that the guests now have, which brings the total up to $30.

The incorrect solution is: ($10 - $1) x 3 + $2 = $29. This equation is not meaningful: the number 29 is not significant to the problem, i.e. there is no "missing $1".

The correct solution is: ($10 - $1) x 3 - $2 = $25. In this case the solution is the bill amount, which is also the amount of money left in the till.

In other words, $27 is the amount that the guests have paid. Of that $27, $25 went into the till and $2 went to the bellhop. The other $3 is returned to the guests.

This problem provides a means to understand how misdirection, and irrelevant facts and questions, can foil clear analysis. Additionally, the tools used to resolve this paradox are used in the analysis of a wide range of financial and scientific areas.

Misdirection

The problem's second paragraph states five truths:

Each of the guests paid $9; Three times 9 is 27.; The bellhop has $2 in his pocket.; Two plus 27 is $29.; The guests originally handed over $30.;

Unfortunately, No. 4 is a misdirection. In this problem, we wonder about what is going in and out of folks' pockets, and how much is staying there. However, to think about pockets correctly (and to write sensible math), you must mentally draw a circle around each pocket, and count everything that goes in and out of that single pocket. Thus, the equation for one pocket must be derived from what goes in and out of that (same) one pocket. No. 4 confuses what the bellhop kept ($2), and what the guests think they spent ($27), thus mixing up pockets.

Read more at Wikipedia.org





		Zevro Indispensable(tm) Dispenser, 17.5 Oz.			6 Compact Tea Bag Box (Clear) (8.5"L x 5.5"W x 3.5"H) $14.74

		Zevro WMS100 SmartSpace Countertop Dispenser $14.99			Unico Ketchup & Mustard Bottle Set - 12-oz each $3.99

		Tupperware Impressions 2 Qt Pitcher Tangerine $8.75			Old Dutch Large 18/8 Stainless Steel Oil Can Quart Capacity $15.99

		SUGAR DISPENSER $7.98			Mini Salt & Pepper Shakers (MIN-12) $6.91

		Trudeau Syrup Dispenser $8.99			Zevro Single Dry Food Dispenser, White $16.29

		M & M Lazy Boy Dispenser $18.50			Medium Kitchen Scoop by InterDesign $2.49

		Round Condiment Rack, 7.7" (06-1156) $11.51			Syrup Dispenser 16 oz. $9.99

		Pfaltzgraff Ocean Breeze Garlic Keeper $9.99			Arrow Plastic 00066 Mustard And Ketchup Dispensers $1.39

		Elemental Kitchen Oil/Vinegar Dispenser $16.95			12 oz Clear Squeeze Bottle Dispenser H112C1 $1.95

		Zevro GAT 103 Single Indispensable Dispenser - Red $18.20			Beverage Water Drink Dispenser Cooler Office Home $13.99

		Condiment Dispenser 12 oz., 12/BOX $10.69			"Tower" Salt & Pepper Shaker (TOW-1) $11.22

		12 Ounce Squeeze Bottle (06-0523) $1.92			Lexan Cheese Shaker (LX-306AM) $1.86

		6 Ounce Stainless Steel Cocoa Shaker (15-0246) $6.98			Squeeze Dispenser 12 oz. 6 Pkg., 6/PKG $6.99

		Condiment Dispenser 24 oz., 12/BOX $15.19			Toothpick Dispenser (ATD-4S) $12.02

		6 Compartment Condiment Holder (04-0509) $22.64			Squeeze Dispenser 16 oz. 6 Pkg., 6/PKG $9.39

		Condiment Dispenser 8 oz., 12/BOX $10.39			Pump Dispenser Kit Pump kits 1 oz. Adjustable $11.59

		Salt and Pepper Shaker with Lid, 10 Ounce (11-0507) $3.71			1 Pint Insertable Condiment/Garnish Tray (04-0110) $1.81

		1 Quart Insertable Condiment/Garnish Tray (04-0111) $2.91			12 Ounce Clear Squeeze Bottle (06-0535) $20.36

		12 Ounce Red Squeeze Bottle (06-0536) $20.36			12 Ounce Yellow Squeeze Bottle (06-0537) $23.11

		4 Pint Stainless Steel Condiment Dispenser (04-0122) $23.50			5 Ounce Cruet Wire Rack (06-0657) $22.84

		6 Ounce Stainless Steel Cinnamon Shaker (15-0245) $6.98			6 Ounce Stainless Steel Nutmeg Shaker (15-0247) $6.98

		6 Ounce Stainless Steel Vanilla Shaker (15-0248) $6.98			60 Ounce Clear Tuffex I Three-Lip Dexlux Pitcher (06-0018) $11.51

		8 Ounce Cheese Shaker (06-0594) $19.74			Arrow Plastic 00068 Bar-B-Q Dispenser With Baster Brush $3.49

		CanRollerÂ® Can Dispenser for Pepsi FridgeMate and Coke/Miller FridgePack Cartons. Includes 2 units per $9.99 order $9.99			Cheese Shaker Glass 12 Oz. (90PT) $15.83

		Cheese Shaker, 10 Ounce (11-0506) $3.71			Clear Toothpick Dispenser (06-0711) $12.66

		Condiment Jar with Lid, 8 Ounce (11-0564) $5.21			Condiment Jars and Rack Polycarbonate Jar With Lid $6.69

		Condiment Rack Holds 3 (06-0661) $2.38			Dispenser 48 oz. Beige Top $14.49

		Dispenser 48 oz. Grey Top $14.49			Dispenser 48 oz. Orange Top $14.49

		Dispenser 48 oz. Red Top $14.49			Dispenser 48 oz. Yellow Top $14.49

		Dripcut Server 48 oz. Almond Top $15.49			Drop Dispensing Bottle - 2 Ounce $2.99

		Finely Ground Shaker, 10 Ounce (11-0508) $3.71			Igloo 8090 Water Cooler Cup Dispenser $14.23

		Ketchup 12 Oz. Bottle -6, 6/PKG $6.59			Ketchup Saver (06-0516) $4.72

		Large Wire Rack Condiment Caddy (06-0658) $16.92			Lid for 6 Ounce Glass Condiment Jar (06-0656) $24.53

		METAL AND GLASS CANDY DISPENSER $15.00			Mustard 12 Oz. Bottle -6, 6/PKG $6.59

		Oil and Vinegar Cruets k 12 Per Case (G-600) $7.01			Paneled Glass Salt & Pepper Shakers 1 Oz. (SMT-1) $10.39

		Paneled Glass Salt & Pepper Shakers 24 Per Case (SMT-2) $12.25			PEDOMETER WITH PULSE READER $24.98

		rack s&p with menu holder stainless steel (26C) $24.83			Red Squeeze Bottle, 12 Oz., 12 per case, 12/CS $12.49

		Round Condiment Rack, 6.2" (06-1155) $10.68			Rubbermaid 8257UN92 Cup Dispenser $13.26

		Salt and Pepper Shaker Top for 830973, 12 per bag, 12/BAG $15.59			Semi Round Condiment Rack (06-1154) $13.96

		Shaker with Medium Grind Lid (11-0512) $3.71			Small Wire Rack Condiment Caddy (06-0659) $15.55

		Squeeze bottle: Yellow, 12 Oz., 12 per case, 12/CS $12.99			Squeeze Dispenser 12 oz. 6 per case Ketchup, 6/PKG $6.99

		Squeeze Dispenser 12 oz. 6 Pkg. Mustard, 6/PKG $6.99			Squeeze Dispenser 32 oz. 6 Pkg., 6/PKG $10.49

		Squeeze Dispenser 32 oz., 6 per case, 6/PKG $12.09			Sugar, Salt and Pepper Combination Holder (06-0663) $2.15

		Wire Rack Condiment Caddy (06-0967) $14.34			Zevro MCD101 Indispensable Coffee Dispenser (White) $19.95

		Zevro MSR800 Zero Gravity Magnetic Spice Rack (6 silver canisters) $23.50			Zevro ZSM200 Indispensable Spice Mill Set (Black) $21.27

		Zevro ZSM206 Indispensable Spice Mill Set (Green) $21.30			Zevro ZSM207 Indispensable Spice Mill Set (Orange) $21.30

Home

Contact

Resources

Exchange Links

eBay